Massachusetts Criminal Defense Attorney Blog

According to the Metrowest Daily News Melissa Barbor and Larry Fitzpatrick, both of Framingham, Massachusetts have been charged with Massachusetts Drug Crimes. It was reported that shortly before 7:00 a.m. police arrived with a search warrant at their Alexander Street home. There is no indication about where the police located the drugs nor did the article reference the quantity of the substance seized. The two will be arraigned in the Framingham District Court. It is likely that the prosecution will remain in that court.

Read Article:

http://www.metrowestdailynews.com/news/x49438535/Two-arrested-on-drug-charges-in-Framingham

Massachusetts Drug Defense Lawyers, Possession With Intent, Cocaine, Framingham

From this article I can assume a couple of things. One, the quantity of cocaine is less than fourteen grams. Had the police located and seized fourteen or more grams the charge would have been Trafficking rather than Possession With Intent to Distribute Cocaine. Two, the apartment lies within one thousand feet of a school zone. There are often successful defenses to cases such as this. If the search warrant was not properly issued the defendants can mount a constitutional challenge to the search. If a judge agrees that their rights were violated the remedy is usually suppression of the illegally seized substances. The result will be a dismissal of the case. Sufficiency of the evidence is also a defense in many cases like this one. The district attorney must prove that both defendants not only knew that the drugs were in the home but that both shared the intent to distribute the substances. Absent corroborating statements from the defendants this can be a difficult burden to sustain as to both defendants.

Continue reading "Two Framingham Residents Charged With Possession With Intent To Distribute Cocaine, School Zone Violation" »

This past Sunday Sokhanara Chea of Lynn, Massachusetts was arrested in Lawrence after allegedly discharging a firearm into the air on Franklin Street. Shortly after midnight police officers patrolling that area heard four to five shots fired in the Common Street area. When they arrived at the scene they observed two men walking away from one another. One of the men opened a car door and placed something in it. Having just seen the police the individual then started to run. When he was apprehended he fought with the police. The firearm was located under the seat of the car. Five shell casings were located on the sidewalk nearby. Chea has been charged with Carrying a Firearm, Discharging a Firearm Within 500 feet of a Building and Leaving a Firearm Unattended. The case is currently being prosecuted in the Lawrence District Court.

Read Article:

http://www.eagletribune.com/punews/local_story_055003908.html

Lawrence Massachusetts Gun Cases

Carrying a Firearm in Massachusetts is a felony in Massachusetts proscribed by Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 269 Section 10. A conviction of this offense carries a mandatory minimum eighteen months in the house of correction. Discharging a Firearm Within 500 Feet of a Building carries no minimum mandatory sentence. To prove the carrying charge the district attorney must show that Chea had possession of the gun. This begs the question: Did he put the gun in the car? If he did and he was not licensed to carry the firearm he faces the mandatory minimum sentence. The article states that the police did not actually see him place the weapon in the car. Rather, his actions suggested that he was secreting the weapon in the car to avoid detection. This makes no sense. When the police arrived they saw two men walking in opposite directions seemingly trying to avoid the police. One of them, supposedly Chea, opened the car and put the gun in the car under the seat. This takes time and seems unlikely for someone who is trying to escape from a crime scene. A more natural reaction would be to run and throw the gun somewhere. Whose car was this? People in that neighborhood do not usually keep their cars unlocked. If it was Chea's car why would he walk towards it and put the gun inside knowing the police were after him. As to the second charge, there is no indication that anyone actually saw him shoot the gun. This might be a defensible case.

Continue reading "Lynn Man Facing Gun Charges In Lawrence" »

Authorities allege that Michael Fitzpatrick of Malden assaulted an Arlington woman at gunpoint in the Dock Square garage yesterday at 1:00 in the afternoon and took off in her SUV. Apparently this incident was witnessed by two other women who sheltered the victim and got her out of the garage. Fitzpatrick made his escape from the garage by driving through the gate. He later drove into a taxi cab fleeing that scene as well. Fitzpatrick got into another accident in the North End and was apprehended shortly thereafter. A loaded firearm was recovered at the scene and Fitzpatrick was positively identified by the first victim. At arraignment it was learned that the defendant had been drinking a half gallon of vodka per day. This case is being prosecuted in the Boston Municipal Court. Fitzpatrick also has a case pending in the Quincy District Court.

Read Article:

http://www.boston.com/news/local/breaking_news/2010/02/man_arrested_af_5.html

Massachusetts Carjacking Lawyers

The law on Carjacking in Massachusetts is set out in M.G.L. ch. 265 Secton 21A. It states that anyone who steals or tries to steal a motor vehicle by putting a person in fear or by assaulting the person is guilty of Carjacking, a felony. If the crime is committed with a firearm there is a minimum mandatory five year state prison sentence that must be served. Given his criminal history and the nature of this offense it is likely that the district attorney will be looking for Fitzpatrick to serve some serious state prison time. A possible defense or certainly a mitigating factor is the quantity of alcohol that the defendant had ingested at or near the time of the crime.

Continue reading "Malden Man Charged With Carjacking In Boston Municipal Court After Taking SUV At Gunpoint" »

Yesterday morning at about 9:30 a local taxicab driver called 911 claiming that he had been robbed at gunpoint. The complainant stated that he picked Shayne Sullivan up at his home on 256 Market Street, drove him to an address on Pawtucket Boulevard and then back to 256 Market Street. Sullivan supposedly paid the driver then placed a gun against his head and stole from him some money. When police responded and located Sullivan they were told that he had made some threatening statements. Consequently the SWAT team was called to the scene. Sullivan was apprehended. He was charged with Armed Robbery on a person over sixty years old. The case is pending in the Lowell District Court.

Read Article: http://www.lowellsun.com/ci_14447660

Lowell Criminal Defense Lawyer Robbery Cases

Armed Robbery is a felony that carries with it a possible life sentence. Many times robbery cases are reduced to Larceny so that the case can be prosecuted in the district court. This occurs when the district attorney believes that there can be a fair resolution of the case can be reached without having to send the defendant to state prison. The gravity of the defendant's actions, the impact to the victim and mental health concerns are some factors that can prompt the prosecutor to reduce the charges. Here, the gun was not real, the victim was not physically injured and the defendants' irrational actions (i.e. robbing someone in front of his own home) suggest the possibility that this case might not be indicted.

Continue reading "Lowell Man Suspected Of Robbery Arrested With Help Of SWAT Team" »

In January of this year, in the case of Presley v. Georgia the United States Supreme Court ruled that included in the Sixth Amendment right to a public trial is the right to have the courtroom open during the jury selection process. Presley was tried and convicted of Cocaine Trafficking in Georgia. Before the impanelment process began an individual was observed sitting in the courtroom. The person was Presley's uncle. Over objection the trial judge excluded the defendant's uncle until after the jury had been chosen. After his conviction Presley appealed to the Georgia appellate courts. Both its Court of Appeals and its Supreme Court affirmed the verdicts. The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari and reversed the Georgia court rulings. In doing so the Supreme Court relied on the Sixth Amendment right to a public trial. Included in this right is the jury selection process. The Court in Presley recognized that in an earlier ruling under the First Amendment the public could not be excluded from the jury selection process.

The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court reaffirmed this rule in Commonwealth v. Cohen. Both the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court and the United States Supreme Court have suggested that there may be situtations where closure is necessary. In those instances however the trial court must find that the party looking to close the courtroom have an overriding interest that is likely to be prejudiced, the closure must be limited to that need and no more, the trial judge must consider reasonable alternatives and the trial court must make findings supporting the decision to close the courtroom.

Click here to read Presley v. Georgia.

Continue reading "United States Supreme Court Rules That Right To Public Trial In Criminal Cases Extends To Impanelment Process" »

Paul Souza, a Boston Police Fire Department lieutenant has been charged with OUI, Malicious Destruction to Property Over $250, Assault and Battery and Failure to Stop from a Police Officer stemming from his involvement in an incident in Braintree this past Friday. According to reports, Souza cut off a car that pulled out of a parking lot in front of him. Souza then confronted the driver, broke his window, shouted obscenities at him and fled. The victim followed Souza. He called the police. Souza then tried to evade the police who ultimately apprehended him. The police detected alcohol on Souza's breath and indicated that he was uncooperative at the time of the stop. The case is pending in the Quincy District Court.

Read Article:

http://www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2010/02/16/boston_firefighter_charged_in_braintree_road_rage_incident/

Quincy, Massachusetts OUI, Assault and Battery Lawyers

Cases like this are difficult for Massachusetts Criminal Defense Lawyers to defend successfully at trial. The district attorney would use Souza's behavior as his or her best evidence of the OUI charge. They would argue that alcohol either triggered his violent behavior or prevented him from maintaining his composure. Trying to evade the police and being aggressive upon apprehension are also factors that would support their position. Given Souza's rank it is unlikely that he has a criminal record. I would imagine that his lawyer will be successful in getting these charges continued without a finding. A consequence will probably include the 24D program and perhaps anger management counseling. I am willing to bet that this case does not go to trial.

Continue reading "Boston Firefighter Charged In Quincy With OUI After Road Rage Incident" »

Eugenio Echevarria and Franklin Echevarria have both been charged with Robbery after a deal for the purchase of tire rims went bad. According to reports, the victim is a nineteen year old Brockton man who had agreed to buy the rims from the Echevarrias. The three met and agreed to a price of nine hundred fifty dollars. The victim then left to get some money. When he returned he got into the defendants car. A gun was placed to his head, his money was stolen and he was ordered out of the car. Police arrived, located the defendants and found the money. No firearm was located. The Echevarrias have been charged with Armed Robbery. The case is pending in the Quincy District Court.

Read Article: http://www.enterprisenews.com/news/cops_and_courts/x814065553/Two-charged-with-robbing-Brockton-man-in-Quincy

Quincy, Massachusetts Armed Robbery Cases

Cases like this one are often defended successfully by Experienced Criminal Defense Lawyers in Massachusetts. There appears to be much more to this case than has been reported by the purported victim. If the Echevarrias had robbed this man and believed they were going to be apprehended they would do much more than get rid of the gun. They would have gotten rid of the money as well. There is no evidence other than the word of the victim that a crime occurred. Perhaps he regretted the deal he got himself into and this is how he intends to get his money back. This is a great case to defend and it would not surprise me to see the defendants get acquitted. This does not look like a true Massachusetts Armed Robbery Case.

Continue reading "Quincy, Worcester Men Charged With Armed Robbery Of Brockton Man" »

Paul Robinson of Rockland, Massachusetts was arrested last week after employees of a Dunkin' Donuts reported that he had exposed himself to them several times since last October. Apparently the manager of the store had reported the activity days before the arrest but no one was able to locate the suspect. Later, Robinson was found near the store. He was questioned and subsequently identified by store employees through photographs as the person who had exposed himself. Robinson was arrested and faces several counts of Open and Gross Lewdness. The case will be prosecuted in the Hingham District Court.

Read Article:

Massachusetts Man Who Exposes Himself Several Times Charged In Hingham

Open and Gross Lewdness in Massachusetts

Open and Gross Lewdness in Massachusetts is a crime in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 272 Section 16. The law states that "[a] man or woman, married or unmarried, who is guilty of open and gross lewdness and lascivious behavior, shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for not more than three years or in jail for not more than two years or by a fine of not more than three hundred dollars." This is a felony and a conviction could result in consequences before the Sex Offender Registry Board (SORB). In order to convict someone for Open and Gross Lewdness the district attorney must prove that the accused intentionally exposed genitals, breasts, or buttocks, that he or she did so openly or with reckless disregard of public exposure in a manner so "as to produce alarm or shock"; and the action actually shocked one or more persons. Flashing in the manner described in this article can at times satisfy the elements of this offense.

Continue reading "Rockland Man Charged With Open And Gross Lewdness In Hingham District Court" »

Mia Richburg of Boston has been charged with Arson stemming from a fire set to 263 Essex Street in Lynn, Massachusetts this past fall. It is alleged that Richburg called Ernest Taylor, her son's father on September 16, 2009 and learned that he was at work. She and a friend then drove to Lynn and broke into the home. Once inside Richburg lit the bedroom on fire. Richburg was also charged with Breaking and Entering in the Daytime with the Intent to Commit a Felony.

Read Article:

Massachusetts Woman Facing Arson Charges In Essex County

Arson in Massachusetts

Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 266 Section 1 states that anyone who "wilfully and maliciously" sets fire to a home is guilty of Arson. The crime is a felony. It is punishable by up to twenty years on state prison and a fine of up to ten thousand dollars. This article suggests that Richburg's friend provided law enforcement with the information needed to secure an indictment. The article also suggests that Richburg had some form of motive for committing the crime, something that works to her detriment if this case goes to trial. The fact that this case indicted to the Superior Court rather than prosecuted in the district court gives a strong indication that the prosecution is looking for some sort of jail time for this defendant. This case seems like the type of case that a Massachusetts Arson Defense Lawyer might look to plea bargain. Where there is no minimum mandatory sentence the judge will have great discretion in imposing a sentence.

Continue reading "Boston Woman Charged With Arson In Lynn Indicted " »

Jamald Harrold is facing charges in the Essex County Superior Court in Salem, Massachusetts for Assault With a Dangerous Weapon, Trafficking Cocaine, Receiving a Stolen Motor Vehicle and a School Zone Violation. The case stems from a December 22, 2009 incident where Harrold got into a confrontation with his former girlfriend's brother. It is alleged that Harrold pulled a knife on the man who in turn armed himself with a baseball bat. Police were called. When they arrived they observed the defendant in a motor vehicle that had been reported stolen a few days earlier. Inside the car the police found over twenty eight grams of cocaine.

Read Article:

Lynn, Massachusetts Man Looking At 7 Years Mandatory For Dealing Cocaine

Trafficking Cocaine in Massachusetts

The sentence for Cocaine Trafficking in Massachusetts rests primarily on the quantity of the substance that was sold or intended for sale. Over 28 grams mandates a five year state prison sentence. Add another two years to that conviction due to the school zone violation. The defenses to this case likely involve the ability of the prosecution to convince a jury beyond a reasonable doubt that Harrold knew that the drugs were in the car. Keep in mind that Harrold was charged with Receiving a Stolen Motor Vehicle, not Larceny of a Motor Vehicle. Implicit in this is the fact that he did not steal the car. It is also conceivable that whoever he borrowed the car from took never let him know that the car was stolen. Similarly, it is not inconceivable that that person was responsible for the drugs in the car, not Harrold.

Continue reading "Lynn Man Charged With Trafficking Cocaine, Receiving Stolen Motor Vehicle Held On Bail" »

On Saturday Min Deng was arrested and charged with Prostitution after Framingham, Massachusetts police responded to an advertisement on "craigslist" for "adult services". A Framingham police sergeant who was searching the website found a listing for the services. He responded and met with Deng at her apartment. Deng offered Sex for a Fee after which she was arrested. Deng's arraignment is set for February 17, 2010 in the Framingham District Court.

Read Article:

Prostitution Charges For Woman Offering Massages Out Of Framingham Apartment

Prostitution in Massachusetts

Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 272 Section 53A makes Prostitution in Massachusetts a misdemeanor, punishable by up to one year in the house of correction. Massachusetts Criminal Lawyers with experience defending prostitution cases can usually get charges for first time offenders dismissed with court costs or continued without a finding. In this case it is interesting that Deng could not be arraigned because there was no Mandarin interpreter to translate the proceedings yet the officer investigating the case contends that she negotiated specific sex acts for certain fees. How did he know what she was saying given that she was offering massage services and a massage table was set up in the apartment. I am sure that Deng's lawyer will explore this issue in mounting a defense. Absent a lengthy criminal record I would not be surprised to see this case resolved favorably for the defendant.

Continue reading "Woman Living In Framingham Charged With Prostitution After Cop Responds To Advertisement For Massage Services" »

About a year and a half ago police in Pepperel were called for a report of a Motor Vehicle Break-In. The 911 caller gave police a descrption of the subject who fled prior to the police arrival. While investigating the report the police noticed a cigarette butt in the driveway. They kept it as evidence and had it tested for DNA. Around this time there were about a dozen or so reported car breaking in this area. A credit card was stolen from one of the cars. It was determined that Derek Delosh used the credit card to make a purchases. Delosh told the police that he obtained the credit card from Jordan Alves. Upon further investigation the authorities learned that Alves' DNA was on the cigarette butt. Alves is charged with twenty counts of Breaking and Entering a Motor Vehicle and Larceny. The charges are pending in the Ayer District Court.

Read Article:

DNA Helps Cops Charge Locals With Breaking And Entering Motor Vehicle

Breaking and Entering a Motor Vehicle in Massachusetts

Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 266 Section 18 makes it a crime for anyone to break into a motor vehicle with the intent to commit a felony. A conviction of this offense is punishable by up to ten years in state prison. The underlying felony in this case is larceny which is punishable by up to five years in state prison. Alves DNA on the cigarette butt coupled with Delosh's statements are enough to sustain the criminal charges in this case. Absent a description from the victim or other evidence such as fingerprints on the vehicle a conviction might be more difficult to secure, particularly if Delosh does not testify for the prosecution.

Continue reading "DNA Evidence Leads Police To Suspect In Unsolved Breaking And Entering Cases" »